Monday, June 13, 2016

Crime and Punishment in my kid's world



One of the hardest part about being a parent is knowing how much force to use, and what is appropriate when it comes to punishment. This is illustrated by the different ways my 4 year old Sam and 2 year old Roland address and react to my wife and me.
Sam is a very truthful guy. Even when he's at his most stressed and tired, he always airs on the side of truth. As an example; the other night Sam was freaking out because he was tired. He hit his brother, and threw a toy at him. When I sent Sam to his room, a few minutes later I went in there to sit with him. I asked him candidly "Why did you hurt your brother?" He went with his stock response "because I wanted to." Sam is funny in this way, if he's feeling obstinate, he will always answer in the negative of what he's asked.

"Are you happy?" "No, I'm sad."

"Do you love your brother?' "No, I don't like him."

"Are you a human?" "No, I'm an alien."

This is the only time Sam will not say what's on his mind, and he gives in to a rebellious nature. In my eyes, it is an attempt to control his environment when he loses control. The best thing we can teach him is that, as long as he follows the rules, life is a lot easier on him. When he gets out of line, he gets his privileges taken away. Now there are times that he completely loses his shit and someone needs to "close the door" as we put it. That can include me or Christa just sitting with him while he freaks out, or as much as putting him in a hug and not letting him go until he agrees this isn't the best way to express himself. He also can just need time in his room by himself, but it's hard to know which is best in a given situation. Christa and I can only do what feels right in that moment, and adapt if it doesn't work.
When he finally calms down, we can deconstruct. The answers become truthful. Sam didn't like Roland doing whatever so he hit him. We then talk about further consequences, and typically, if Sam has calmed down, he understands. He doesn't always make the right choices, but he's 4 and that's to be expected at times.




Roland is totally different. Roland, though 2, looks very much like a toddler at this point. He doesn't have the easy going attitude Sam has. Roland operates in a world where he gets to do whatever he wants, whenever he wants. He learned how to disagree from Sam, but has yet to understand that his actions have any sort of consequences whatsoever. The hardest part is that Roland will pinch or hit Sam, and then cries when Sam hits him back. This is due to his age. Roland has the unique perspective of seeing how we react to, and interact with Sam.

Roland is completely averse to the idea that anything he does may have negative consequences. Any sort of punishment for Roland is difficult because we can't withhold something from him, because he just doesn't get that things might be correlated. He doesn't have the slightest idea that he hits his brother with a toy, he may lose that toy. All he sees is he fights with his brother, which he doesn't like, then he loses his toy, which he REALLY doesn't like. I hope soon he will start making this connection.



No comments:

Post a Comment